I'll keep my brainstorming here, and color them blue when I make decisions!
Prelude (30 mins.)
When You Say Nothing at All by Alison Krauss
The One by Gary Allen
Bless the Broken Road by Rascal Flatts
And So it Goes by the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
When God Made You by Natalie Grant
I Will Be Here by Steven Curtis Chapman
I Can Love You Like That by John Michael Montgomery
I Do (Cherish You) by Mark Wills
The One by Gary Allen
Bless the Broken Road by Rascal Flatts
And So it Goes by the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
When God Made You by Natalie Grant
I Will Be Here by Steven Curtis Chapman
I Can Love You Like That by John Michael Montgomery
I Do (Cherish You) by Mark Wills
Ceremony
Seating of the families:
I Loved Her First by Heartland
My Wish by Rascal Flatts
Mama's Song by Carrie Underwood
I Believe in You by Steven Curtis Chapman
Wedding Party Processional:
Wassermusik composed by George Frideric Handel
Ode to Joy
I Can Only Imagine by MercyMe
Pachelbel's Canon in D composed by Johann Pachelbel
Bridal Processional:
Pachelbel's Canon in D composed by Johann Pachelbel
Concerning Hobbits composed by Howard Shore
Hymns:
Great is Thy Faithfulness
Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee
'Tis So Sweet to Trust in Jesus
I Love You, Lord
Be Thou My Vision
You're Beautiful by Phil Wickham (Personal favorite, but not necessarily one the guests will be familiar/comfortable with)
Recessional:
Ode to a Butterfly by Nickel Creek
Stumptown by Nickel Creek
Ever Ever After by Carrie Underwood
Postlude:
House of Tom Bombadil by Nickel Creek
Somewhere Over the Rainbow by Israel Kamakawiwo'ole
My Heart Will Go On by Jake Shimabukuro
Appalachia Waltz by Edgar Meyer
Star of County Down by Edgar Meyer
Reception
First Dance:
I Cross My Heart by George Strait
Father/Daughter Dance:
Baton Rouge by New Grass Revival ( It's our song. :D )
Cutting of the Cake:
Sugar, Sugar by The Archies (So cute!)
Build Me Up Buttercup by The Foundations
Forever and Ever, Amen by Randy Travis
Bouquet Toss:
Girls Just Wanna Have Fun by Cyndi Lauper
Who I Am by Jessica Andrews